• 2 Posts
  • 64 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: August 8th, 2023

help-circle








  • The subjectiveness of it being a superior product aside.

    Brave is chromium under the hood and therefore contributes to the rendering engine homogeneity that leaves Google in control of web standards.

    Iirc they are keeping some support for manifest v2 , for now. It’ll be interesting to see how that plays out for them both financially and from a technical upkeep point of view.

    I’d guess it doesn’t last long, but haven’t looked at it hard enough to have an informed opinion on it.


  • That’s also a logical fallacy.

    You are conflating lack of effective choice with active support.

    In an effectively two party race, where both arguably are supporting a position (through action if not through ideology) there is no option where you aren’t effectively contributing to said position.

    Vote either way or not at all , you are contributing to the overall success of one party or the other.

    “Our genocide guy is better” is really the only option when there is no other practical choice.

    Even voting independent just supports whoever happens to be winning from the two main parties.

    What are you proposing is the practical option for people who don’t want to be “in support of parties involved in committing genocide”?

    To be clear i have no good answer to this either, just wondering if you do.


  • Senal@programming.devtoAtheism@lemmy.mlBook Club
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    Personally, I define a cult as either an NRM (The more common use in the 20th century) or a local sect (the more common use in antiquity)

    Sure, but that’s a fairly narrow definition that ignores a large proportion of the actual dictionary definitions.

    I am politically motivated not to consider Christianity a cult, because I believe it makes unjust apology for Christianity

    A somewhat subjective take that doesn’t really explain how the term cult would imply “unjust apology”

    Cults are, politically speaking, groups which have been targeted by the Satanic panic

    Not true, by any commonly accepted definition of the word.

    edit: the term cults can include groups “targeted by the Satanic panic” but that isn’t a strict definitional requirement.

    The fact that Christianity is not a cult

    Christianity does in fact meet many of the dictionary definitions of the word “cult”.

    You could argue that the normalisation of christianity excludes it from adhering to the definitions that mention “unorthodox” or “small” but those definitions are relatively few.

    and that anti-cult religious leaders have not labelled Christianity a cult, is historically important.

    How so ?

    Other than power and money i mean.

    We can’t go using words in a way that implies Christianity is the victim and confuses the history. I object to calling Christianity a cult precisely because I think ill of Christianity.

    I can’t find any reference to the word “cult” that, when applied to christianity. would absolve them of the egregious historical shitfuckery perpetrated by and for them.








  • TL;DR;

    The rules might be considered a list of “immoral things” but in my experience it was treated more as a list of “distracting things”, YMMV.


    Then why is it on the list of horrible things?

    You mean the list specifically titled “precepts” ?

    It does indicate that it’s a list based on what is considered “moral conduct” so i suppose it could be considered a list of “Immoral” things.

    I personally read it as “Rules and Guidelines to prevent distraction during the process”.

    While i don’t personally prescribe to that kind of moral absolutism i was willing to adhere to the guidelines for a short period to experience the process in it’s intended form.

    Attendance isn’t mandatory so people will have to make that call for themselves if they are considering going.

    The list doesn’t mention communication, and in fact specifically prohibits lying. That suggests that speacking truly is permitted,

    The section titled “Noble Silence” 4 paragraphs down, specifically goes in to the details of the non-communication i was referencing.

    and this is a list of bad things

    Not sure what you mean here, but hopefully i’ve covered it above.

    That’s a list someone makes when they don’t approve of sex (or intoxicants, but that’s another conversation).

    Very possibly and i’d guess it comes from the Buddhist origins.

    I will state that my experience is that it wasn’t preachy at all, the video recordings do reference some Buddhist stories/teachings but only really to use them as examples for teaching the meditation process.

    Given that you aren’t supposed to be communicating in general there is very little leeway in which preaching could occur.


  • It’s not considered bad , but it is a distraction, there’s supposed to be no communication between attendees.

    It’s supposed to be full introspection, afaict.

    Don’t know if its the same in all places but men and women were completely separate in the one I went to.

    Even if you went with your wife you’d not really be there with her, you’d be two people in the same place at the same time, not communicating.

    It’s not really a relaxing holiday kind of place.


  • I genuinely have no idea if it’s an option for you or if it’d even help but for 10/11 days of relative isolation you could try vipassana

    Not sure what the northern US wait times are like, but you generally need to book ahead.

    It’s free, it works on a volunteer basis, no idea how if it works for people with no fixed abode but proof of residence was not required where i am.

    Do check if it’s suitable for you though, there are rules (albeit not many), they seem reasonable to me but might not be for you.

    Isolation wise, there is no communication between attendees, but there are group meditation sessions (though they are also non-talking).

    The three aspects that weren’t silent :

    • the meditation instruction, it was a one hour-ish video playback per day explaining the process.
    • the final day, discussion is allowed.
    • optional question time with an instructor.