…but I already left yesterday. 👋
You must log in or # to comment.
What was the explanation given, or is it just a generic suspension attached to this message?
Completely generic and it just gives you a few reasons your account may have been banned.
Exactly the same as their subreddit request denials that list about 10 different reasons that might be factors.
Fine, I didn’t want to join you anyway
Grrr, I’m on a 3rd party Lemmy app for Android. Can’t figure out an option to open or zoom on photos like yours.
The main webapp is giving me the same problems. In Chrome I have to right-click on the image and open it in a new tab. I made a posting about it in !lemmy_support@lemmy.ml
As Reddit grew older and larger, there was almost no thoughts on the owner’s part that accounts of over 10 years old being banned was practically a lifetime ban. My /u/RoundSparrow account was banned during the outbreak of war in late 2021, early 2022 due to street-gang factions fighting over disinformation… lost my 15 year old account.
Same goes for subreddits. ‘Ban evasion’ gets you site-wide banned if you create a new account and then after 5 years go contribute in a subreddit you were previously blocked from. It’s a dehumanizing experience, there is no room for growth as a community nor individual.
There is no sense that people and society conflicts change and that individual persons can be caught up in trending topics. “leaving Reddit” is one of said battleground trending topics…
How do they determine you evaded anyway?
Based on my own experience operating websites… my guess is that they keep track of browser strings, IP addresses, and login times - and have some kind of offline job that can study all the same accounts that use the same IP addresses around similar times.
I suspect when when the admin looks at an account they can see information about your IP address history, geolocations, browsers, and detected secondary accounts.
Nah they set a fucking cookie! And the official app links your reddit account to your Google account, when they ban you they save the Google account, if a new account registriers with that account it gets banned automatically, same with the cookie, its really really easy to evade bans when not using the “official” app
Probably. I mean the most obvious thing would be email.
Though my original reddit account never even had an associated email address.
Also keep in mind they have a lot of tools to try and prevent vote manipulation. Even when there are zero email addresses, for over a decade the Reddit code tries to detect if someone logs out and logs in to grant multiple upvotes to the same posting.
Even when it isn’t my own posting, I’ve sometimes upvoted the same posting from two accounts - and see that the count did not go up the same. That’s why I assume there is some kind of underlying awareness within the (server) app that the accounts are related.
On a site like Lemmy and Reddit, vote manipulation is key to getting postings to the top of the page. I imagine Lemmy will eventually encounter rogue federated instances that try to game the system. I remember 10 years ago when Reddit had to start building a lot of anti-spam features into the code. But I really dislike how they black-hole comments based on keywords and I was always opening issues in their /r/Bugs subreddit to complain about their instant removal of comments that had certain keywords (in 2020, posting a link to the BBC about anti-vaccination would trigger it on major subreddits that had their spam filter set high).
Good points all around.
To some extent, that kind of automated moderation is inevitable on a service or site that has millions of users. You just can’t scale a site that large without throwing out some baby with some bathwater, especially if the service is free.
But the same moderation tools were never necessary on services with small communities of users. From BBS’s in the 80s/90s to message boards, small groups don’t need to rely on automated filtering. That’s part of the appeal of joining a small instance on the fediverse: it’s like a club, where standards of behavior don’t need aggressive enforcement.
What’s unknown to me, however, is how the fediverse can handle spam and bots and abuse from outside communities. That’s not something that BBS’s or message boards had to deal with as much.
In a pinch, communities could also deal with the problem by just shutting down federation and being entirely “locals only.” For communities who are often targeted for abuse, that might be the smartest thing to do, unfortunately.
Either way, I like the format of it so far. Cross-posting to lemmy.ml, for example, I feel like a “guest” in this group, if that makes sense.
That too, verified email addresses would be the most obvious way.
I have had 43 accounts and i never was caught “ban evading” and reddit wasn’t able to do shit… Idk i literally always picked fights with people that abused the system to oblivion (u/awkwardturtle to be specific)
Its been a long journey on reddit, but it came to an end.
I just hope reddit dies now.
@Wilshire Ironic that the same thread is discussing power-tripping mods.
I see you edited out all the usernames. Is that required on the Lemmy instance you use, or are you just following Reddit’s community conventions about not sharing usernames when posting screen shots?
I guess I’m a weird privacy nerd, bc they didn’t consent to have their comments reposted here.
reddit is now called redShit, because how it’s managers try to wreck it. it’s why I call twitter shitter fedi will thrive. and destroy every other social platform!
